Einstein's class

Einstein's class

World Nuclear News

AREVA North America: Next Energy Blog





EMC2

Sunday, May 15, 2011

Fwd: Japan Disaster Raises the Larger Question (once again): Is Nuclear Power Safe?



---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: atul baride <barideatul@gmail.com>
Date: Sun, May 15, 2011 at 3:52 AM
Subject: Fwd: Japan Disaster Raises the Larger Question (once again): Is Nuclear Power Safe?
To: barideatul.Real@blogger.com




---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: Sukla Sen <sukla.sen@gmail.com>
Date: Sun, Mar 13, 2011 at 8:27 AM
Subject: Japan Disaster Raises the Larger Question (once again): Is Nuclear Power Safe?
To: Konkan Bachao Samiti Mumbai <kbsamiti.mumbai@gmail.com>
Cc: Aditya Aman <aditya.aman@aajtak.com>, Aarti Bhalerao <aartibhlr2@gmail.com>, Abhijit Hegshetye <abhijithegshetye@yahoo.com>, Abhishek D <abhidan@gmail.com>, Afternoon D&C <afternoonnews@gmail.com>, Ahmed Manzoor <ahmedmanzooor@gmail.com>, Ajit Mandhare <ajit.mandhare@ibnlokmat.tv>, Ajit Ujjainkar <aujjainkar@gmail.com>, Ajit Waykar <ajitswaykar@gmail.com>, Alka Dhupkar <alka.dhupkar@ibnlokmat.tv>, All India Radio <rnumumbai@gmail.com>, Alok Deshpande <alok.desh86@gmail.com>, Alpana Pant Sharma <alpanapsharma@hotmail.com>, Amey V Polekar <amey_polekar@rediffmail.com>, Amit Sitaram Joshi <amitjoshi101@gmail.com>, ANI <ani_mumbai@rediffmail.com>, Anil Singh <anilsinghjournalist@gmail.com>, Anoop Radhakrishnan <anoopr@asianetnews.in>, Anubha Bhosale <abhonsle123@gmail.com>, Anuj Chopra <kafkacrazy@gmail.com>, Apoorva Salkade <apoorvasalkade@gmail.com>, Arti Kulkarni <arti.kulkarni@ibnlokmat.tv>, Ashish Singh <jurno.ashish@gmail.com>, Bhaskar Paul <bhaskar@intoday.com>, Charul Bajaj <bajajcharul@gmail.com>, Chitra Sawant <chitrasawant@gmail.com>, Dharmendra Jore <dharmendra.jore@hindustantimes.com>, DNA <dnaindia@gmail.com>, E TV <etvnews.mumbai@etv.co.in>, Faizal Vythiri <faizalvythiri@gmail.com>, FPJ <fpj@vsnl.com>, George Koshy <george.koshy@bloombergutv.com>, Gopal Krishna <krishna2777@gmail.com>, Hamara Mahanagar <hmahanagar@gmail.com>, Hari Govind Vishwakarma <hgvkarma@gmail.com>, Harshada Parab <harshadasp@gmail.com>, J Dey <j.dey@mid-day.com>, Jagruk Times <jagruktimes@yahoo.co.in>, "Jayan T.V." <tvjayan@gmail.com>, Kavita Sharma <kavi.journalist@gmail.com>, Kinjal Pandya <pandya.kinjal@yahoo.com>, Kishor Satam <kishoresatam@rediffmail.com>, Kumar Ashoke <kumarashoke.raj@gmail.com>, Kundan Sawant <kundan_sawant@rediffmail.com>, Lina Mathias <lina@epw.in>, Makarand Gadgil <makarand.gadgil@ubm.com>, Manish Mehta <apin007@gmail.com>, Meena Menon <meenamenon@gmail.com>, Miloni Bhatt <miloni@ndtv.com>, Monideepa Mukharjee <monideepa2002@yahoo.co.in>, Mrityunjay Bose <mrityunjaybose@gmail.com>, Navakal <navakal@vsnl.com>, Neeta Kolhatkar <neetakolhatkar@gmail.com>, Nikhil Ghanekar <ghanekar.nikhil@gmail.com>, Om Prakash Tiwari <omtiwari24@gmail.com>, PIB_Mumbai <pibmumbai@gmail.com>, Praful Bidwai <praful@bol.net.in>, Prasanna Zore <prasannaz@rediff.co.in>, Prashant Nakwe <prashantnakwe@gmail.com>, Prashant Rangnekar <rangnekarprashant@gmail.com>, Pratahkal <pratahkal@gmail.com>, Pratyush Narayanan <pnarayanan9@bloomberg.net>, Priyanka Kakodkar <priyak@ndtv.com>, PTI_Mumbai <ptimumrepo@yahoo.com>, Pudhari <pudhariabc@rediffmail.com>, Rajan Chaughule <rajanchaughule@gmail.com>, Rakesh Trivedi <rakesh.ibn7@gmail.com>, Rakshit Sonawane <rakshitsonawane@expressindia.com>, Rashmi <rashlucky9@gmail.com>, Ravindra Ambekar <ibn7mumbaiassignment@network18online.com>, Reshma Jathar <reshmajathar@gmail.com>, "Ritvick A. B." <ritvickanimum@gmail.com>, Rohit Chandavarkar <rohitchandavarkar@gmail.com>, Sachin Rohekar <sachinrohekar@gmail.com>, Samana <saamana@vsnl.net>, Sanjay Deshpande <funnyletters@gmail.com>, Sanjay Hadkar <sanjayhadkar@gmail.com>, Sanjay Jog <ssjog70@hotmail.com>, Sanjay Sawant <sanjays@rediff.co.in>, Satish Nandgaonkar <satishnandgaonkar@gmail.com>, Shoaib Ahmed <shoaib.ah@gmail.com>, Shruti Shetty <shettyshrithi@gmail.com>, Snehal Rebello <snehal.rebello@gmail.com>, Snigdha Hasan <snigdhahasan@yahoo.co.in>, Sugandh Juneja <sugandh@cseindia.org>, Sunil Chawake <sunilchawake@expressindia.com>, Supriya Patwardhan <supriyapatwardhan@gmail.com>, Suresh Bhatewara <suresh.bhatewara@gmail.com>, Surya Singh <surya.singh@aajtak.com>, Susheel Pareek <animumbai@gmail.com>, Swati Lokhande <swatil@starnews.co.in>, Toral Varia <toral.varia@gmail.com>, UNI <unimumbai@gmail.com>, Urdu Times <urdutimesdaily@gmail.com>, Varsha Arolla <varshaarolla@gmail.com>, Velly Thevar <velly.thevar@abp.in>, Vinaya Deshpande <vinideshpande@gmail.com>, Vipin Nair <vnair12@bloomberg.net>, Vivek Bhat <vishvek11@gmail.com>, Yatish Yadav <yatish.yadav@newsx.com>, Yogesh Pawar <p.yogesh@dnaindia.net>, Yogesh Pawar <yogeshp1969@gmail.com>, Yogi Aggarwal <yogi.aggarwal@gmail.com>, Manoj Lele <manojplele007@rediffmail.com>, Pramod Konkar <sakaalrtn@gmail.com>, Ratnagiri Express <rtg_express@rediffmail.com>, Ratnagiri Lokmat <rtn_lokmat@rediffmail.com>, Ratnagiri Sakaal <rtn_sakaal@gmail.com>, Ratnagiri TBD <rtg_tbd@rediffmail.com>, Ratnagiri Times <timesrtn@rediffmail.com>, Sunil Nalavade <sunil_nalavade@yahoo.co.in>, "Agence France Presse (AFP)" <bombay@afp.com>, Arko Datta <arko@arkomail.com>, Danish Siddiqui <ahmadanish@gmail.com>, Devsagar Singh <singhdevsagar@rediffmail.com>, Indranil Mukherjee <indranil.mukherjee@afp.com>, Pia Heikkila <piaheikkila@hotmail.com>, Rhitu Chatterjee <rhituparna.chatterjee@gmail.com>, Vaiju Naravane <vaijunaravane@aol.com>, Vineet Khare <vineetkhare@gmail.com>, "(Purnviram) Weekly" <editor@purnviram.co.in>, "(Sainik Bharti)" <sainikbharti@yahoo.co.in>, "(MT)" <colourmt@gmail.com>, "(IBN Lok) Amruta Durve" <amruta.durve@ibnlokmat.tv>, "(IBN Lok) Govind Tupe" <govind.tupe@ibnlokmat.tv>, "(IBN Lok) Priyanka Desai" <priyanka.desai@ibnlokmat.tv>, "(IBN Lok) Uday Jadhav" <uday.jadhav@ibnlokmat.tv>, "(India News) Abhishek Sharma" <abhisheiknsharma@gmail.com>, "(India Tv) Prakash Tiwari" <prakashtiwari@indiatvnews.com>, "(India Tv) Sachin Chaudhary" <sachinchaudhary@indiatvnews.com>, "(India Tv) Vivek Agrawal" <vvagrawal@gmail.com>, "(Lemon Tv) Devendra Kolhatkar" <devendra.kolhatkar@gmail.com>, "(Lemon Tv) Shahid Ansari" <shahid.ansari@lemontv.in>, "(Live Ind/Mi Marathi) Sandeep Patwal" <sandeep.patwal87@gmail.com>, "(Live India) Anjani Kumar Mishra" <anjani.mishra72@gmail.com>, "(Live India) Avinash Pandey," <avinash.pandey@liveindia.tv>, "(Live India) Hitendra" <hitendra.liveindia@gmail.com>, "(Live India) Mahendra Singh" <mwassingh@gmail.com>, "(Live India) Neha Purav" <neha.purav@gmail.com>, "(Live India) Rahul Sharma" <rahulsharma021@gmail.com>, "(Mahuaa) Sarita Bhardwaj" <bnbnews@rediffmail.com>, "(Manorama) Jaimon George Sr Reporter" <jaimongeorge@mm.co.in>, "(Manorama) Jayaprakash M" <jppattambi@gmail.com>, "(Media) Kapil Chandni" <kapilchandni@gmail.com>, "(NDTV) Dharmendra Tiwari" <tiwari.dharam@gmail.com>, "(NDTV) Ketki Angre" <ketki@ndtv.com>, "(NDTV) Mahek Jain" <mahakj@ndtv.com>, "(NDTV) Rashmi Rajput" <rashmir@ndtv.com>, "(NDTV) Sunchika Pandey" <sunchikap@ndtv.com>, "(NDTV) Tejas Mehta" <tejas@ndtv.com>, "(News 24) Ankur Tyagi" <ankur_tyagi83@yahoo.com>, "(News 24) Bhupendra Singh Thakur" <bhupenthakur@gmail.com>, "(News 24) Preeti Sompura" <pritisompura@yahoo.co.uk>, "(News 24) Vivek" <vivek.isomes@gmail.com>, "(News X) Deborah Grey" <greyfrost1013@gmail.com>, "(News X) Rahul Dubey" <rahul.dubey@newsx.com>, "(News X) Ronak" <ronak.kotecha@gmail.com>, "(News X) Sarthak Bagchi," <sarthak1987@gmail.com>, "(News X) Tanya Adarkar" <adarkartanaya@gmail.com>, "(P 7) Pradeep Pande" <pradeep.pande@rediffmail.com>, "(Saam Marathi)" <saammumbai@gmail.com>, "(Saam Marathi) Nirzar Barve" <nirzarmbarve@gmail.com>, "(Sahara Mumbai) Rahul Asthana" <rahulasthana84@yahoo.com>, "(Sahara Samay National) Akhilesh Tiwari" <akhiltiwari77@gmail.com>, "(Sahara Samay) Manoj Bhoier," <ashayshodh@gmail.com>, "(Sahara Samay) Manoj Bhoyar" <manoj.bhoyar@saharasamay.com>, "(Sahara Samay) Niranjan Takle Assignment Head" <niranjantakle@gmail.com>, "(Sakshi TV) Phaniraj K" <phani_saakshi123@yahoo.com>, "(Star Mazha) Jitendra Dixit Bureau Chief" <jitendradixit@starnews.co.in>, "(Star Mazha) Mayank Bhagwat" <babba.mayank@gmail.com>, "(Star News) Vijay Salvi" <vijaysalvi@starnews.co.in>, "(Times Now) - Ashish Singh" <ashishindia101@yahoo.com>, "(Times Now) Jugal Purohit" <purohit.jugal@gmail.com>, "(TV 9) Ishan choudhary" <ishanchoudhary@gmail.com>, "(TV 9) Raju Parulekar" <raju.parulekar77@gmail.com>, "(TV 9) Tushar Shete" <tusharshete@tusharshete.com>, "(Tv Today) Aariz" <aarizs.chandra@aajtak.com>, "(Tv Today)Vidya" <vidyas@journalist.com>, "(UNI tv) Assignment Mumbai UNI TV" <mumbai.uni@gmail.com>, "(UNI tv) Kamar Ansari Assignment head" <kamar.ansari@unitv.in>, "(UNI Tv) Shailendra Kumar Singh" <shailendrajournalist09@gmail.com>, "(Zee News) Priyanka Wankhade" <wankhade.priyanka@gmail.com>, "(Zee News) Somdatt" <ssomdatt@gmail.com>, "(Aft Noon D&C) Azad Shrivastav" <azadshrivastav@gmail.com>, "(Asian Age) Anand Shinde" <sjnanand@gmail.com>, "(Asian Age) Rajesh Jadhav" <rajesh7029@gmail.com>, "(Asso Press) Rajanish Kakade" <rajanish21@gmail.com>, "(Bus Line) Shashi Ashiwal Photo" <shashiwal@gmail.com>, "(Business Std) Kamlesh Pednekar" <kamlesh.pednekar@gmail.com>, "(DNA) Mukesh Trivedi" <t_mukesh@dnaindia.net>, "(DNA) Sherwin Crasto" <sherwincrasto@dnaindia.net>, "(DNA) Swapnil Sakhare" <sakhare.swapnil@gmail.com>, "(DNA) Vipin Pawar" <vipinpawar@dnaindia.net>, "(Eenadu) Pravin Kajrolkar" <pravinphotos@gmail.com>, "(European Pressphoto Agency)Divyakant Solanki" <divyakant.solanki@gmail.com>, "(F lancer) Deepak Thombre" <dgt18671@yahoo.com>, "(F lancer) Ravindra Zende" <ravindrazende03@gmail.com>, "(F lancer) Sandeep Mahankal," <smahankal@gmail.com>, "(Fauji) Sunil Gawade" <sunilagawade@gmail.com>, "(FPJ) Ghanshyam Bhadekar" <gbhadekar@gmail.com>, "(Hindu) Vivek Bendre" <vivekbendre@yahoo.com>, "(HT) Hemant Padalkar" <hemant.padalkar@hindustantimes.com>, "(HT) Kunal Patil" <kunalfoto@gmail.com>, "(HT) Manoj Patil" <manoj@v3mail.com>, "(HT) Puneet Chandhok," <puneet.chandhok@hindustantimes.com>, "(Ind Exp) Ganesh Sirsekar" <ganeshshirsekar@gmail.com>, "(Ind Exp) Prashant Nadkar" <prashantnadkar@gmail.com>, "(Live)Sunil Shirsekar," <livephoto05@gmail.com>, "(Mb La'dweep) Bhushan Koyande" <bhushankoyande@gmail.com>, "(Mb Mirror) Deepak Turbhekar," <deepakturbhekar@gmail.com>, "(Mb Samachar) Amey Kharade" <amaykharade@gmail.com>, "(Mb Samachar) Nicholas Yarde" <nicholasyarde@gmail.com>, "(Media) Anshuman Poyrekar" <anshumanpoyrekar@gmail.com>, "(Media) Prashant Nadkar" <prashantnadkar@yahoo.com>, "(Media) Rajesh Age" <rajeshage@gmail.com>, "(Media) Sandeep R Singh" <sandeep.singh291182@yahoo.co.in>, "(Nai Duniya) Girish Srivastav" <ptigirish@gmail.com>, "(Prahar) Vinamra Acharekar," <vinamra.acharekar@prahaar.co.in>, "(PTI) Mohan Bane" <mohan.bane@gmail.com>, "(PTI) Shirish Shete" <shirishgs@gmail.com>, "(Pudhari) Suresh Jadhav" <pudhari.photo@gmail.com>, "(Rashriya Sahara) Gautam Sen" <sengautam@yahoo.com>, "(Sakal Times) prashant sawant" <prashantsawant2000@gmail.com>, "(Thanthi) S S Sundaram," <dtsundarphoto@gmail.com>, Arun Velaskar <mlcpiarun@gmail.com>, "Dr. Vivek Monteiro" <vivekmonteiro@yahoo.com>, "Konkan Bachao Samiti, Pune" <kbsamiti.pune@gmail.com>, Madhu Mohite <mmrmohite@yahoo.com>, Mangesh Chavan <mangeshchavan007@gmail.com>, Sanjay Singhavi <xsanjayx@gmail.com>, Aditya Khebudkar <adya.kk@gmail.com>, Ajit Gaunekar <ajitaman@gmail.com>, Akhilendra Pratap Singh <apsinghtikrikala@yahoo.com>, Amruta Walimbe <walimbeamruta@gmail.com>, Anand Patwardhan <anandpat@gmail.com>, Anand Sarup <sarupanand@hotmail.com>, Anand Tangsali <atangsali@yahoo.com>, Aruna Roy <arunaroy@gmail.com>, Asmita MJ <asmitamj@yahoo.com>, Bala Gavankar <rgavankar@rediffmail.com>, Bhanudas Dhuri <dhuri.bhanudas@gmail.com>, "Com. Uday Choudhari" <shambuksu@gmail.com>, Datta Desai <dattakdesai@gmail.com>, Dipankar Bhattacharya <liberation@cpiml.org>, "Dr. Ajit Nawale" <ajitnawale_2007@yahoo.co.in>, "Dr. Aparna Watve" <aparnawatve1@gmail.com>, "Dr. Arun Mitra" <idpd2001@hotmail.com>, "Dr. N. P. Chaubey" <issaald@gmail.com>, "Dr. Subodh Wagle" <subodhwagle@gmail.com>, "Dr. Sudhir Paranjape" <paranjape51@yahoo.co.in>, "Dr. Tetali Pundarikakshudu" <tetalip@gmail.com>, Heffa Schücking <heffa@urgewald.de>, Jaya Mehta <jaya_mehta@hotmail.com>, Joy K J <joykjjoy@gmail.com>, K Ashok Rao <kashokrao@gmail.com>, Krishnakant <tokrishnakant@gmail.com>, Lalita Ramdas <lalitagpi@gmail.com>, Lata P M <latapm@gmail.com>, Lollyramu Ramdas <lramdas@gmail.com>, Milind Pandit <panditmm@yahoo.com>, Mukta Ashok <muktaashok@yahoo.com>, Prakash Sohoni <pks_1555@yahoo.co.in>, Pravin Gavankar <pravingawankar@gmail.com>, Pravin Nadkar 'IFTU' <pnadkar@yahoo.com>, "Prof. S. V. Ranade" <svranade2001@yahoo.co.in>, Rafeeq Ellias <wanderingfakir@hotmail.com>, Rajan Raje <rajan.raje@yahoo.com>, Ravi Kadam <mitra.ravindra@gmail.com>, Roshan <roshan@resist.ca>, "S. P. Shukla" <manjuspshukla@gmail.com>, Sanjeev Chandorkar <sanchan_2011@rediffmail.com>, Sanjeev Sane <neetasanjeev@hotmail.com>, Sanjyot Deuskar <sanjyot.deuskar@gmail.com>, Sanober Keshwaar <ksanober@gmail.com>, Santosh Thakur <thakursantoshn@gmail.com>, Saraswati Kavula <skavula09@gmail.com>, Satyajit Chavan <satyajitchavan@yahoo.co.in>, Shirish Medhi <shirishmedhi@yahoo.com>, Singamsetty Bhujangarao <space.disabled@yahoo.co.in>, Suhas Mainkar <mainkar.suhas@gmail.com>, Suniti Vinay <andolan.sunitivinay@gmail.com>, Surekha Sule <surekha52@yahoo.com>, Tejal Kanitkar <tejal.kanitkar@gmail.com>, Vasant Shirali <shirali_vasant@rediffmail.com>, Vineet Tiwari <comvineet@gmail.com>, Yogesh Kamble 'Muktiyaan' <muktiyaan@gmail.com>, Yusuf Meherally Center <yusufmeherally@gmail.com>, Ashish Kothari <ashishkothari@vsnl.com>, Bhakti Nefertiti <bhakti.nefertiti@greenpeace.org>, Bittu Sahgal <bittu@sanctuaryasia.com>, Deepak Apte <spiderconch@gmail.com>, "Dr. Vivek Bhide" <bhidemangoes@gmail.com>, Lauri Myllyvirta <lauri.myllyvirta@nordic.greenpeace.org>, Milind Wani <milindwani@yahoo.com>, Parth Bapat <parthbapat@gmail.com>, Pradeep Indulkar <pradeepindulkar@hotmail.com>, Anil Vagal <bhagirathiproducts@yahoo.co.in>, Atul Baride <barideatul@gmail.com>, Avinash Kadam <avinashh58@yahoo.com>, Bal Jagtap <baljagtap@yahoo.com>, Deepti Anjarlekar <anjdeepti@rediffmail.com>, "Dr. Anant Phadke" <anant.phadke@gmail.com>, "Dr. Arvind Redkar" <dr_arvindredkar@yahoo.com>, "Dr. Hemu Adhikari" <hemuadhikari@gmail.com>, "Dr. Manjusha Pandav" <drpandav@gmail.com>, "Dr. Mohan Deshpande" <mohandeshpande.aabha@gmail.com>, "Dr. Paresh Vaidya" <pr_vaidya@yahoo.com>, Ganesh Chindarkar <ganeshc@aambyvalley.com>, Geeta Mahashabde <geeta_uam@yahoo.com>, Joseph Pinto <sangatizuzay@gmail.com>, Milind Kale <kale.milind@gmail.com>, Nitin Thatte <nitthatte@yahoo.com>, Pradeep Deshpande <proton54@gmail.com>, Prafull Pandav <prafullp@gmail.com>, Prakash Burte <burte.burte@gmail.com>, Prerana Rane <prerana_rane@yahoo.com>, "S. N. Guttikar" <guttikarsn@gmail.com>, Seema Ketkar <seemaketkar@hotmail.com>, Shaila Mane <smmane14@hotmail.com>, Shalmali Redkar <shalmali_for_friendz@yahoo.co.in>, "Subhir M. R." <subhir14@yahoo.com>, Subodh More <subodhvidrohi@hotmail.com>, Suhas Paranjape <suhas.paranjape@gmail.com>, "Com. Prakash Karat" <cc@cpim.org>, "Com. Sitaram Yechury" <yvsitaram@gmail.com>, Dinesh Abrol <dinesh.abrol@gmail.com>, "Dr. Ashok Dhawale" <ashokdhawale@yahoo.co.in>, "Dr. D. L. Karad" <dr.dlkarad@gmail.com>, Kiran Moghe <kiranmoghe@gmail.com>, Kumar Shiralkar <kumarshiralkar@gmail.com>, "Dr. A. Gopalakrishnan" <agk37@hotmail.com>, "Dr. EAS Sarma" <eassarma@gmail.com>, Abhijit अभिजित <abhijit13@gmail.com>, Amjad Borkar <borkaraal@gmail.com>, "Dr. Arjun Makhijani" <arjun@ieer.org>, "Dr. Benjamin K. Sovacool" <bsovacool@nus.edu.sg>, "Dr. Helen Caldicott" <info@helencaldicott.com>, "Dr. Milind Desai" <milind.desai95@gmail.com>, "Dr. SP Udayakumar" <drspudayakumar@yahoo.com>, "Dr. Surendra Gadekar" <anumukti@gmx.net>, "Dr. Suvrat Raju" <suvrat.raju@gmail.com>, M V Ramana <m_v_ramana@yahoo.com>, "Prof. Banwarilal Sharma" <azadi.bachao.andolan@gmail.com>, Shri Prakash <prakash.shri@gmail.com>, Praful Bidwai <prafulbidwai@gmail.com>, "Com. A. D. Golandaz" <adgolandaz@hotmail.com>, "Com. D. Raja" <rajacpi@yahoo.co.in>, "Com. Dr. Bhalchandra Kango" <bkkango@gmail.com>, "Com. Govind Pansare / Megha Pansare" <megha_pansare@rediffmail.com>, "Com. Prakash Reddy" <comrade.reddy@gmail.com>, "Com. Sushil Lad" <sushillad@yahoo.com>, "Dr. Bharat Karia" <dr.bharatkaria@gmail.com>, Prakash Vishwasrao <lokvangmayagriha@gmail.com>, Sukumar Damle <sukumar_damle@yahoo.co.in>


Quote
The word "meltdown" goes to the heart of the big nuclear question - is nuclear power safe?
Unquote


12 March 2011 Last updated at 13:44 GMT
Exodus from Japan nuclear plant

By Richard BlackEnvironment correspondent, BBC News

The word "meltdown" goes to the heart of the big nuclear question - is nuclear power safe?

The term is associated in the public mind with the two most notorious accidents in recent memory - Three Mile Island, in the US, in 1979, and Chernobyl, in Ukraine, seven years later.

You can think of the core of a Boiling Water Reactor (BWR), such as the ones at Fukushima Daiichi, as a massive version of the electrical element you may have in your kettle.

It sits there, immersed in water, getting very hot.

The water cools it, and also carries the heat away - usually as steam - so it can be used to turn turbines and generate electricity.

If the water stops flowing, there is a problem. The core overheats and more of the water turns to steam.

The steam generates huge pressures inside the reactor vessel - a big, sealed container - and if the largely metal core gets too hot, it will just melt, with some components perhaps catching fire.

In the worst-case scenario, the core melts through the bottom of the reactor vessel and falls onto the floor of the containment vessel - an outer sealed unit.

This is designed to prevent the molten reactor from penetrating any further. Local damage in this case will be serious, but in principle there should be no leakage of radioactive material into the outside world.

But the term "in principle" is the difficult one.

Reactors are designed to have "multiply redundant" safety features: if one fails, another should contain the problem.

However, the fact that this does not always work is shown at Fukushima Daiichi.

The earthquake meant the three functioning reactors shut down. But it also removed the power that kept the vital water pumps running, sending cooling water around the hot core.

Diesel generators were installed to provide power in such a situation. They did cut in - but then they cut out again an hour later, for reasons that have not yet been revealed.

In this case, redundancy did not work.

And the big fear within the anti-nuclear movement, as used in the film The China Syndrome, is that the multiple containment of a molten core might not work either, allowing highly radioactive and toxic metals to burrow into the ground, with serious and long-lasting environmental impacts - total meltdown.

However, the counter-argument from nuclear proponents is that the partial meltdown at Three Mile Island did not cause any serious effects.

Yes, the core melted, but the containment systems held.

And at Chernobyl - a reactor design regarded in the West as inherently unsafe, and which would not have been sanctioned in any non-Soviet bloc nation - the environmental impacts occurred through explosive release of material into the air, not from a melting reactor core.

To keep things in perspective, no nuclear accident has caused anything approaching the 1,000 short-term fatalities stemming from Friday's earthquake and tsunami.

'Subcritical' reactors

Whether a partial meltdown is under way at Fukushima Daiichi is not yet clear.

The most important factor is summed up in a bulletin from the Tokyo Electric Power Company (Tepco) that owns the facility: "Control rods are fully inserted (reactor is in subcritical status)."

Control rods shut off the nuclear reaction. Heat continues to be produced at that stage through the decay of radioactive nuclei - but that process in turn will begin to tail off.

Intriguingly, Ryohei Shiomi, an official at Japan's Nuclear Safety Commission, is widely quoted as having said a meltdown was possible and that officials were checking.

Meanwhile, a visually dramatic explosion in one of the reactor buildings has at least severely damaged the external walls.

In principle, this should not cause leakage of radioactive material because the building is just an outside shell; the job of keeping dangerous materials sealed in falls to the the metal containment vessel inside.

Chief cabinet secretary Chief Yukio Edano confirmed this was the case, saying: "The concrete building collapsed. We found out that the reactor container inside didn't explode."

He attributed the explosion to a build-up of hydrogen, related in turn to the cooling problem.

Under pressure

The only release of any radioactive material that we know about so far concerns venting of the containment vessel.

When steam pressure builds up in the reactor vessel, it stops some of the emergency cooling systems working, and so some of the steam is released into the containment vessel.

However, according to World Nuclear News, an industry newsletter, this caused pressure in the containment vessel to rise to twice the intended operating level, so the decision was taken to vent some of this into the atmosphere.

In principle, this should contain only short-lived radioactive isotopes such as nitrogen-16 produced through the water's exposure to the core. Venting this would be likely to produce short-lived gamma-ray activity - which has, reportedly, been detected.

One factor that has yet to be explained is the apparent detection of radioactive isotopes of caesium.

This is produced during the nuclear reaction, and should be confined within the reactor core.

If it has been detected outside the plant, that could imply that the core has begun to disintegrate.

"If any of the fuel rods have been compromised, there would be evidence of a small amount of radioisotopes in the atmosphere [such as] radio-caesium and radio-iodine," says Paddy Regan, professor of nuclear physics at the UK's University of Surrey.

"The amount that you measure would tell you to what degree the fuel rods have been compromised."

It is an important question - but as yet, unanswered.

Cover-ups and questions

In fact, the whole incident so far contains more questions than answers.

Parallels with Three Mile Island and Chernobyl suggest that while some answers will materialise soon, it may takes months, even years, for the full picture to emerge.

How that happens depends in large part on the approach taken by Tepco and Japan's nuclear authorities.

As with its counterparts in many other countries, Japan's nuclear industry has not exactly been renowned for openness and transparency.

Tepco itself has been implicated in a series of cover-ups down the years.

In 2002, the chairman and four other executives resigned, suspected of having falsified safety records at Tepco power stations.

Further examples of falsification were identified in 2006 and 2007.

In the longer term, Fukushima Daiichi raises several more very big questions, inside and outside Japan.

Given that this is not the first time a Japanese nuclear station has been hit by earthquake damage, is it wise to build such stations along the east coast, given that such a seismically active zone lies just offshore?

And given that Three Mile Island effectively shut down the construction of civilian nuclear reactors in the US for 30 years, what impact is Fukushima Daiichi likely to have in an era when many countries, not least the UK, are looking to re-enter the nuclear industry?



--
Peace Is Doable